Skip to content
3D Design Studios

Guide

Shop drawings vs submittals, construction drawings and as-builts

By 3D Design Studios ·

On a US project, four sets of documents are mixed up all the time: the construction drawings, the shop drawings, the wider submittal package and the as-built or record drawings. They are made by different people, at different stages, for different readers. Here is what each one is, who prepares and reviews it, and where shop drawings sit in the submittal process.

Construction drawings: what to build

The construction drawings, often called the contract drawings or CDs, come from the architect and the engineers. Together with the specifications they are part of the Contract Documents: they define what the finished building must be, with its dimensions, materials and performance. They rarely show how one manufacturer's system is cut, fastened or sequenced, because the design team does not yet know which product or installer will be used.

Shop drawings: how one part will be built

AIA's A201 General Conditions (2017 edition, section 3.12) describe shop drawings as drawings, diagrams, schedules and other data that the contractor or a subcontractor, manufacturer or supplier prepares specially for the project. In practice they translate the design into one system and one installer: exact panel sizes, joint locations, fastener and clip layouts, and the detail at every edge and opening.

Shop drawings sit outside the Contract Documents. Their job is to set out the contractor's intended way of meeting the design, and they never change it. A change the owner or design team wants goes through a change order or another formal modification, never through a shop drawing.

Submittals: the wider package

"Submittal" is the umbrella word. A201 groups shop drawings with product data, the manufacturer's published information marked up to show the model, options and finish chosen, and with samples, physical examples of a material or of workmanship, from a color chip to a full mockup. Every shop drawing is a submittal, but most submittals are not shop drawings.

The project manual says what each trade must submit: once in the Division 01 submittal procedures section (01 33 00 in CSI MasterFormat), and again in the "Submittals" article of each technical section. A Division 07 cladding package, for example, usually calls for shop drawings, product data sheets, color samples, test reports and warranty information.

Who draws them, and who checks them

The contractor or the trade doing the work prepares the shop drawings, in house or through a drafting firm, and the general contractor checks them before they go to the architect. The architect and engineers then review them for a limited purpose: conformance with the design concept and the information in the Contract Documents. They are not checking every dimension, and their review does not take over the contractor's responsibility for means, methods and coordination between trades.

Each submittal comes back with an action stamp. The exact wording comes from the specification, but a set usually comes back marked "Revise and resubmit" or "Rejected", or released with "No exceptions taken" or "Furnish as corrected". A revise-and-resubmit returns to the drafter and goes out again as a numbered revision.

Delegated design: when a seal is needed

Some specifications hand part of the design to the contractor, for example the attachment of a cladding system to the structure. Those submittals are signed and sealed by a licensed professional engineer, as the AIA General Conditions and most specifications require. A drafting firm can prepare the drawings to that engineer's design, but the calculations and the seal stay with the engineer. That is how we work: drafting only, with engineering and stamps left to the project's engineer or the system manufacturer.

As-built drawings and record drawings

As-built drawings record what was really built. During construction the contractor marks up a set of the drawings with every change: moved openings, rerouted services, substituted products. At closeout those mark-ups become the record drawings handed to the owner, usually under the project record documents section of the specification (01 78 39 in MasterFormat). Usage varies: some owners call the marked-up set the as-builts and the clean final set the record drawings, while others treat the words as one.

As-builts look back at the finished building; shop drawings look ahead to fabrication and installation. Bringing the shop drawings into line with what was installed is a common closeout task on cladding and envelope packages.

The four documents side by side

  • Construction drawings: by the architect and engineers; show what to build; part of the Contract Documents
  • Shop drawings: by the contractor, a trade or a supplier; show how one portion will be made and installed; reviewed, but not part of the contract
  • Submittals: shop drawings plus product data, samples, test reports and warranties, as Division 01 and each technical section require
  • As-built and record drawings: marked up during construction and handed over at closeout; show what was actually built

What a reviewer looks for in a cladding shop drawing

  • Sheet numbers, titles and a revision history that match the submittal log
  • Elevations with every panel or course laid out and dimensioned
  • Wall sections that show each layer: cladding, cavity, continuous insulation, weather barrier and sheathing
  • Details at window heads, sills and jambs, corners, the base of the wall, floor lines and parapets
  • Product names and specification section numbers on the sheets
  • Clouded changes and a written answer to every comment from the last round

Sources

Common questions

Do shop drawings form part of the contract?

No. Under the AIA General Conditions, shop drawings, product data and samples are submittals that sit outside the Contract Documents; they record the contractor's plan for meeting the design.

Who is responsible for errors in shop drawings?

The contractor. The design team only checks that the drawings follow the design concept; dimensions, quantities and coordination between trades remain the contractor's job.

Can shop drawings be outsourced?

Yes. Many subcontractors and building product manufacturers send their shop drawings to a drafting firm and keep the checking and coordination in house. The set is issued under the contractor's own title block.

Is a fabrication drawing the same as a shop drawing?

Not quite. A shop drawing is reviewed by the design team and shows how a system fits the building. A fabrication drawing is for the plant or shop floor and gives the cut sizes and part numbers of each piece. On many cladding jobs one set does both.

What is the difference between as-built drawings and record drawings?

As-builts are usually the contractor's marked-up drawings from the field; record drawings are the final set compiled from them and handed to the owner at closeout. Some owners use the two terms for the same thing.